7 Best Pizza Spots In Lahaina, Maui

7 Best Pizza Spots In Lahaina, Maui

Some of the links in this post are affiliate links. This means if you click on the link and purchase the item, I will receive an affiliate commission at no extra cost to you. Opinions expressed here are the author’s alone. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See our Advertising Policy

Aloha, pizza lovers!

In the land of swaying palm trees, breathtaking sunsets, and pristine beaches, Hawaii offers more than just an idyllic paradise. Amidst the lush tropical landscapes, Lahaina boasts a delightful and diverse pizza scene and the best pizza spots in Lahaina, Maui are just waiting to be discovered.

From traditional Italian-style pies to inventive fusion creations, there’s a slice for every palate in Lahaina. Join me as I take you on a culinary adventure, exploring the best pizza spots in Lahaina that will have you saying “ono” (delicious) in no time!

So get out of your hotel and get ready for some spots that will make your mouth water.

All of Maui has been significantly impacted due to the recent fires. Check directly for up-to-date information and consider donating via a trusted Maui charity. I will keep this list up on the website in hopes that some of these amazing places will open again and can benefit from the SEO link. I will continue to monitor and adjust accordingly.

Prison Street Pizza

Prison Street Pizza one of the best pizza spots in Lahaina
Photo courtesy of Prison Stree Pizza

Prison Street Pizza, located in the charming town of Lahaina on the picturesque island of Maui, offers a memorable pizza experience that both locals and visitors adore.

Known for its cozy and inviting atmosphere, this popular eatery serves up a delightful mix of New Jersey-style thin-crust pies, using only the freshest and highest quality ingredients. Their diverse menu caters to a wide range of preferences, featuring classic favorites alongside innovative island-inspired creations.

Pizza Paradiso

7 Best Pizza Spots In Lahaina, Maui
Photo courtesy of Pizza Paradiso

Pizza Paradiso, a beloved gem in the vibrant town of Lahaina on Maui’s stunning coastline, is a haven for pizza enthusiasts seeking a heavenly slice.

Renowned for its warm, welcoming atmosphere and a menu that celebrates Mediterranean and Italian flavors, Pizza Paradiso provides a dining experience that delights both the palate and the soul. Combining the finest locally-sourced ingredients with traditional techniques, their culinary team crafts a diverse array of delectable pizzas and other mouthwatering dishes that cater to every taste.

Whether you’re craving a classic Margherita or venturing into the world of island-inspired creations, Pizza Paradiso invites you to embark on a gastronomic journey that captures the essence of Aloha spirit and the irresistible allure of Lahaina’s pizza scene.

Lahaina Pizza Company

7 Best Pizza Spots In Lahaina, Maui
Photo Courtesy of Lahaina Pizza Company

Lahaina Pizza Company, situated in the heart of Lahaina on the mesmerizing island of Maui, is a cherished destination for pizza lovers seeking a memorable dining experience.

This bustling eatery, known for its friendly service and inviting atmosphere, serves up a delightful array of deep-dish and thin-crust pizzas that cater to all taste buds. Fusing classic Italian flavors with a touch of Hawaiian flair, Lahaina Pizza Company’s menu offers a wide selection of creative and delicious options. As you indulge in the mouthwatering pies and soak in the stunning ocean views, you’ll be transported to a place where the Aloha spirit and the art of pizza making come together.

This makes the Lahaina Pizza Company a must-visit spot for any pizza enthusiast exploring the beautiful shores of Hawaii.

Sale Pepe

7 Best Pizza Spots In Lahaina, Maui
Photo Courtesy of Sale Pepe

Sale Pepe Pizzeria e Cucina, tucked away in the lively town of Lahaina on Maui’s captivating coastline, is an extraordinary culinary destination for pizza connoisseurs and Italian food lovers alike.

This authentic Italian eatery, celebrated for its warm hospitality and elegant atmosphere, specializes in crafting artisanal Neapolitan-style pizzas, expertly prepared in their traditional wood-fired oven. Using only the finest ingredients imported from Italy and locally sourced from the island, Sale Pepe offers a menu that showcases the perfect balance of classic and innovative flavors. As you savor each exquisite bite, you’ll be transported to the heart of Italy, while still embracing the Aloha spirit of Maui.

A visit to Sale Pepe Pizzeria e Cucina promises an unforgettable gastronomic journey that’s not to be missed when exploring Lahaina’s vibrant pizza scene.

Pizza Madness Maui

7 Best Pizza Spots In Lahaina, Maui
Photo Courtesy of Pizza Madness Maui

Pizza Madness Maui, nestled in the bustling town of Lahaina on the scenic island of Maui, is a paradise for pizza enthusiasts seeking a deliciously satisfying experience.

This casual, laid-back eatery has quickly become a favorite among locals and tourists alike, thanks to its dedication to serving mouthwatering, hand-tossed pizzas made from scratch. Using only the freshest ingredients and a passion for excellence, Pizza Madness Maui offers an extensive menu that caters to a variety of tastes, with options ranging from classic favorites to inventive, island-inspired concoctions.

As you relish each delightful slice in the cozy, welcoming atmosphere, you’ll discover why Pizza Madness Maui is an essential stop for anyone looking to indulge in the irresistible flavors of Lahaina’s thriving pizza scene.

Round Table Pizza Maui

7 Best Pizza Spots In Lahaina, Maui

Round Table Pizza Maui, located in the bustling town of Lahaina on the picturesque island of Maui, offers a familiar and beloved pizza experience for those exploring the vibrant local scene.

As part of the well-known Round Table Pizza chain, this family-friendly eatery maintains its commitment to quality and taste by serving a wide variety of scrumptious pizzas crafted with fresh, premium ingredients. The extensive menu caters to all preferences, featuring classic Round Table favorites and innovative island-inspired options to satisfy every craving.

With its welcoming atmosphere and dedication to exceptional customer service, Round Table Pizza Maui ensures a delightful dining experience.

These are the best pizza spots in Lahaina and all have over 4-star reviews. Let me know if there is a new on I need to add to the list or maybe one that needs to come off.


  1. Why do your reviews not include any information on prices? Or at least a ranking of highest to lowest?

    • Including pricing is tough since it changes so often over multiple locations, I choose to just provide a link to the Google listing of the location and someone can click through to get current pricing. Ranking highest to lowest is something I have thought about and usually just end up giving my favorites spot and let the others fall where they may. My current favorite is Kapena’s on Maui, Diamonds on Kauai, and Bostons Aikahi on Oahu.


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.