7 Best Ice Cream Shops In Maui | Island Guide

Growing up in Hawai’i I had the chance to live on both Oahu and Maui, lucky, I know. One thing I enjoyed after a day at the beach besides a plate lunch was Ice Cream. Whether it came in a cup with a wooden spoon or in some fancy container it didn’t really matter back then.

While my tastes have changed over time ice cream has never dropped off my list of favorites. If you find yourself looking for the best ice cream shops in Maui then this list will steer you in the right direction.

Enjoy the scoops below 🙂

All of Maui has been significantly impacted due to the recent fires. Check directly for up-to-date information and consider donating via a trusted Maui charity.

Donut Dynamite

Don’t miss their Malasada Ice Cream Sandwich!

Donut Dynamite is a renowned artisan donut shop located on the beautiful island of Maui, Hawaii.

Famous for its unique and delectable gourmet donuts, the establishment has become a must-visit destination for both tourists and locals alike. Their handcrafted donuts are made from scratch daily, using high-quality, locally-sourced ingredients to create an explosion of flavors and textures.

The menu features various innovative donut flavors, including tropical-inspired options such as lilikoi (passion fruit), guava, and coconut.

The friendly staff, inviting atmosphere, and dedication to quality have helped Donut Dynamite establish itself as a beloved staple in Maui’s culinary scene.

Get all the scoops on Maui here.

Lappert’s Wailea

Renowned for its rich, creamy, and flavorful frozen treats, Lappert’s has captured the hearts of both locals and tourists alike.

With a commitment to using fresh, high-quality ingredients, Lappert’s offers a wide array of flavors, including island-inspired options like Kauai Pie, Mango Sorbet, and Macadamia Nut. In addition to ice cream, they also serve specialty coffee, baked goods, and other delicious treats.

The welcoming atmosphere, friendly staff, and mouthwatering desserts make Lappert’s Ice Cream a must-visit destination for anyone seeking an indulgent, tropical treat in Wailea.

Island Cream Co.

Known for its fresh, delicious, and inventive frozen treats, Island Cream Co. has earned a devoted following among both locals and tourists.

Using high-quality, locally-sourced ingredients, they offer a delightful array of flavors, including island-inspired options like Pineapple Coconut, Lilikoi (passion fruit), and P.O.G. (pineapple, orange, guava).

The shop also boasts a cozy, welcoming atmosphere and a friendly staff that contributes to a delightful customer experience.

Ono Gelato Co.

The founder of Ono Gelato Company is a third-generation gelato artisan hailing from Torino, Italy.

Their authentic Italian gelato masterpieces are prepared daily from scratch using whole milk, heavy cream, and egg yolk. Any ingredients not available locally are imported directly from Italy, ensuring the genuine gelato experience.

A spectrum of island-inspired flavors includes sandy beach, salted caramel, coffee crunch, coconut, macadamia nut, mango, Maui “mokka,” Sicilian pistachio, and timeless favorites such as chocolate, vanilla, strawberry, hazelnut, and cookies & cream. Italian gelato, with its rich and delectable taste, goes beyond being just a dessert.

Additionally, Ono Gelato offers coffees, lattes, frappes, pastries, banana bread, brownies, and cookies at their coffee bar.

Enjoy your chosen treats (and your loved one) while relaxing at Ono Gelato’s charming oceanfront seating area. It’s the perfect spot to unwind. Several Made-on-Maui specialty gifts, including mugs, T-shirts, soaps, and coconut spiced chai and coffee gift packs.

Maui Sweet Shoppe

Maui Sweet Shoppe stands out for several reasons that contribute to its uniqueness:

Island-inspired flavors: The shop incorporates local flavors and ingredients native to Maui, such as tropical fruits and macadamia nuts, creating a distinct taste that sets their confections apart.

Handcrafted treats: Maui Sweet Shoppe takes pride in making its sweets and treats from scratch, ensuring a high level of quality and freshness in every product.

Local sourcing: The shop’s commitment to using locally-sourced ingredients not only supports local businesses and farmers but also adds to the authentic island experience for its customers.

Maui Sweet Shoppe’s unique combination of island-inspired flavors, handcrafted treats, local sourcing, welcoming atmosphere, and commitment to quality make it a truly special destination for anyone looking to indulge in delicious sweets on the island of Maui.

Tasaka Guri Guri Shop

Tasaka Guri Guri is a cherished family-owned dessert shop located on the island of Maui, Hawaii.

Established in 1918, it has been delighting locals and tourists alike for over a century. The shop is famous for its signature dessert, Guri Guri, which is a unique, refreshing, and delicious treat that falls somewhere between sherbet and ice cream.

Guri Guri is made with a secret family recipe passed down through generations. The dessert comes in two classic flavors: strawberry and pineapple, both of which showcase the vibrant, tropical essence of Maui.

The smooth and creamy texture, combined with the fruity flavors, make Guri Guri a perfect treat to enjoy on a warm Hawaiian day.

Tasaka Guri Guri’s longstanding history, commitment to maintaining their traditional family recipe, and delightful, one-of-a-kind dessert have cemented its status as a must-visit destination for anyone seeking an authentic and delightful Maui experience.

Paia Gelato

Paia Gelato is a charming gelato shop located in the laid-back town of Paia on the beautiful island of Maui, Hawaii.

Known for its delicious and authentic Italian-style gelato, Paia Gelato has become a favorite among both locals and tourists seeking a delightful frozen treat.

With a commitment to using high-quality, fresh, and locally-sourced ingredients, Paia Gelato offers a wide range of flavors that cater to various tastes. Their menu includes both classic and island-inspired options, such as vanilla, chocolate, and hazelnut, as well as tropical flavors like coconut, lilikoi (passion fruit), and mango.

The shop also offers dairy-free and vegan options, ensuring that there is something for everyone.

The welcoming and relaxed atmosphere of Paia Gelato, combined with the friendly staff and mouthwatering gelato, makes it a must-visit spot for anyone seeking a refreshing and tasty treat while exploring the enchanting town of Paia on Maui.

Maui Gelato & Waffles

This cozy shop offers an enticing selection of scrumptious gelato flavors and mouthwatering waffles, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Committed to using fresh, high-quality, and locally-sourced ingredients, Maui Gelato and Waffles offers a wide variety of flavors that cater to diverse tastes.

Their gelato menu includes classic favorites as well as unique island-inspired options such as pineapple, coconut, and lilikoi (passion fruit). In addition to the delicious gelato, the shop also serves up freshly made waffles, which can be enjoyed on their own or as a complement to the gelato for a truly indulgent experience.

Coconut Glen’s

Coconut Glen’s is a renowned ice cream shop located along the famous Road to Hana on the island of Maui, Hawaii.

This delightful roadside gem has earned a reputation for its unique and delicious vegan ice cream, which is crafted using coconut milk as its base.

Focusing on fresh, high-quality, and locally-sourced ingredients, Coconut Glen’s offers a variety of flavors that showcase the island’s tropical essence. Some popular options include lilikoi (passion fruit), banana, chocolate, and the classic coconut. The vegan ice cream boasts a creamy, smooth texture that appeals to a wide range of ice cream lovers, including those with dietary restrictions or preferences.

The quirky, colorful, and welcoming atmosphere of Coconut Glen’s, combined with its eco-conscious approach and friendly staff, adds to the shop’s charm. It’s an ideal stop for travelers exploring the Road to Hana who are seeking a refreshing and delectable treat that captures the spirit of Maui.

Hula Cookies & Ice Cream

Founded in 1999 on the picturesque island of Maui, Hula Cookies is a family-owned enterprise that has quickly gained fame not only across the Hawaiian Islands but also throughout the United States for offering the authentic flavors of Hawaii.

Scrumptious gourmet cookies are crafted by hand every day right on Maui, using only the freshest, high-quality ingredients, and without any preservatives or trans fats.

Be sure to try the legendary Roeselani Ice Cream! They take pride in their Gourmet Ice Cream Sandwiches made to order, Roeselani Ice Cream, and the finest shave ice! In need of coffee? They’ve got you covered there as well!

Lahaina Ice Cream Parlour

Situated in the center of Front Street, adjacent to the renowned Banyan Tree in Lahaina, Lahaina Ice Cream Parlour offers an array of delightful treats.

From Lappert’s Ice Cream and Dole Soft Serve to authentic Hawaiian Shave Ice, there’s something for everyone. Just follow the enticing aroma of freshly-made waffle cones to find their location.

BanyanTreats

Situated near the famous Banyan Tree on Front Street, this delightful store offers a variety of delicious desserts and snacks to locals and tourists alike.

The shop features a selection of delicious ice cream flavors, including those from the well-known brand Lappert’s Hawaii. With a range of flavors, from classics like vanilla and chocolate to tropical Hawaiian-inspired options, there’s something for everyone.

They have the popular Dole Soft Serve, a pineapple-flavored soft-serve ice cream that is a refreshing and fruity treat, perfect for enjoying on a warm Hawaiian day.

Hawaiian Shave Ice: The shop serves authentic Hawaiian shave ice, a traditional island dessert made by shaving a block of ice and topping it with flavored syrups. Customers can choose from a variety of flavors and even add extras like ice cream or sweetened condensed milk.

Fresh-made Waffle Cones: BanyanTreats takes pride in making their waffle cones fresh daily, which adds to the delightful experience of enjoying ice cream and other frozen treats.

Snacks and Treats: In addition to their frozen offerings, they also offer a selection of snacks, candies, and other confections to satisfy your sweet tooth.

An excellent stop for anyone looking to indulge in delicious desserts while enjoying the charming atmosphere of Lahaina and its surrounding natural beauty.

Big Wave Shave Ice

Big Wave Shave Ice is a classic hole-in-the-wall type shave ice stand that people seek out on their visits to Maui. Popping up at local events and with limited hours be sure to check where they are before heading over.

Shave ice remains a favorite treat in Hawaii, enjoyed by residents and visitors alike. The dessert has become a symbol of Hawaiian culture, and you can find it at local mom-and-pop shops like Big Wave, food trucks, and even high-end restaurants throughout the islands.

Breakwall Shave Ice

Located near the historic Lahaina Harbor and the famous Banyan Tree Park, Breakwall Shave Ice Co. is a popular spot for both locals and tourists seeking a refreshing treat on a hot day.

The shop is named after the nearby Lahaina Breakwall, a famous surf break that attracts surfers from around the world.

In addition, to shave ice, Breakwall Shave Ice Co. offers other treats, such as acai bowls, smoothies, and coffee. As with many shave ice shops, they also offer unique flavor combinations, as well as local Hawaiian flavors like lilikoi (passion fruit), guava, and mango.

Ululani’s Hawaiian Shave Ice

Ululani’s Hawaiian Shave Ice has multiple location on Maui so check to see if one is near you.

With multiple locations across the island, Ululani’s has become a favorite among both locals and tourists for its high-quality shave ice and exceptional customer service. The company takes pride in using the finest and purest ingredients to create its refreshing and flavorful desserts.

Ululani’s offers a wide variety of flavors, including classic tropical options like pineapple, coconut, and passion fruit, as well as more unique choices such as pickled mango and tiger’s blood (a blend of strawberry and coconut). They also feature local Hawaiian flavors like li hing mui and guava.

Customers can choose from various toppings and add-ons, such as azuki beans, mochi, and a scoop of ice cream, as well as a “snow cap” of sweetened condensed milk drizzled on top.

The shave ice at Ululani’s is known for its soft, fluffy texture that melts in your mouth, setting it apart from coarser snow cones. The company has received numerous awards and accolades over the years, earning a reputation as one of the best shave ice shops in Hawaii.

Gus’ Hawaiian Shave Ice

Remember when your parents told you to never take candy from a stranger in a van? This is the exception.

You will find them curbside in a blue and white VW Van “Bus” that is vintage all the way. More of a food truck operation with variable hours you should check their facebook page to find out where and when they will be open.

Peace Love Shave Ice

The menu at Peace Love Shave Ice features traditional Hawaiian flavors such as passion fruit (lilikoi), guava, and mango, as well as more unique options like lychee and watermelon. Customers can also choose to add toppings like mochi, azuki beans, or a scoop of ice cream to enhance their shave ice experience.

The shop’s laid-back atmosphere and colorful decor make it a popular spot for both locals and tourists seeking a cool and refreshing treat in Kihei.